Jack, Sharon and Keith claim that they were attacked by a shotgun-wielding cowboy as they went to retrieve their football from a nearby house in their suburban neighbourhood. A naive, low budget Production Company pick up their story and attempt to make a documentary about their frightening ordeal. As the events of that fateful night are retold through a series of interviews and dramatic re-enactments, it appears there might be much less to the trio's tale than we first anticipated.