Pastor Scott and his wife, Cindy, are looking for an upgrade over their current house in Jenison, Michigan. The practical-minded Scott wants a new build with plenty of room for themselves and their two boys, plus convenient features like a finished basement, a mud room, and an attached garage. But Cindy wants a place with lots of quirks, colorful walls, and fixtures and unique design features. The last thing she wants is anything cookie-cutter. It could take divine intervention to get them to compromise.