Organising the Easter Fete for the village, Alphy feels like he’s finally found home. Love, however, is proving more elusive. Geordie’s taken to calling him the ‘Reverend-Love-’Em-And-Leave-’Em’. When a suspicious death interrupts the Fete, Geordie suspects foul play. Alphy attempts to use the case as a distraction from his personal life, only for it to lead him to a potential romance.

A death at the university plunges Geordie and Alphy into a world of academic adversaries. Alphy encounters a complication in his romantic life.

Alphy’s attempts to cook a romantic dinner are interrupted when a familiar face arrives unannounced at the vicarage.

Alphy and Geordie investigate witchcraft at a home for orphaned and disadvantaged children run by an old friend of Alphy’s. When a body is found, Alphy struggles to consider his friend as a suspect.

Leonard’s drinking lands him in a prison cell overnight. When he wakes up, the consequences only escalate from there.

Alphy and Geordie investigate when a member of a rock band is murdered. Alphy struggles with some family history.

Cathy and Mrs. Chapman’s new business venture hits a serious obstacle. Geordie tries to intervene in Alphy’s personal life, unbeknownst to Alphy.

Alphy and Geordie keep an eye on rising tensions as a controversial figure is invited to speak at the university. When a murder is committed, however, they disagree on how to approach the case.